Freshman Grant Hunter was named to the first team and 10 of his teammates were selected second team or honorable mention on the 2008 All-Pioneer Football League Team, selected by league coaches.
Hunter, a defensive end, led the PFL in quarterback sacks (14), while finishing second in the league in tackles for loss (18). His 14 sacks tied the second-highest total ever by a Butler football player, trailing only the school-record 17 quarterback sacks by Scott Cook in 1983. Hunter finished his first competitive season with the Bulldogs with 27 solo tackles, 15 assists, one forced fumble, one fumble recovery and one pass breakup. His 14 sacks resulted were for 97 yards lost.
The Bulldogs, who tied for fourth in the final PFL standings, placed three players on the All-PFL second team. Senior placekicker Jordan Quiroz was tabbed second team All-PFL for the second straight year and was named on the All-League team for the third consecutive year. He set a Butler single season record with 42 successful PAT kicks this season, and he finished his career in second place on Butler's all-time list for kick-scoring with 175 points.
Senior linebacker Mike Bennett and junior wide receiver Dan Bohrer also earned second team All-PFL recognition. Bennett was Butler's third-leading tackler this season with 61 stops, and he finished his Butler career with 230 stops. Bohrer set a Butler single season record for touchdown receptions with 11, and he finished second in the PFL in both receptions (71) and receiving yards (971).
Seven additional Bulldogs, including record-setting quarterback Matt Kobli, were awarded honorable mention on the All-League squad. Kobli set a Butler single season mark for touchdown passes with 23, and he posted the second-highest single season passing total in Butler history with 2,518 yards. Sophomore Tadd Dombart was given honorable mention on the All-League team as both a defensive back and as a return specialist. Also receiving honorable mention were freshman running back Dionte Wiggins, senior offensive lineman Rob Noel, sophomore offensive lineman Donny Gilmore, junior linebacker Derek Guggenburger and junior defensive back Spencer Summerville.
Butler finished the 2008 campaign with a 6-5 record, the Bulldogs' first winning season since 1997. The Bulldogs, picked to finish in a tie for seventh in the PFL preseason poll, posted a 4-4 league record and wound up tied with Drake and Morehead State in the final league standings.