Butler University Athletics

* 2015 Third Team All-Northeast Region
* 2015 BIG EAST All-Freshman Team
* 2017 United Soccer Coaches Second Team All-American
* 2017 United Soccer Coaches All-Midwest Region First Team selection
* 2017 BIG EAST Offensive Player of the Year
* 2017 All-BIG EAST First Team 
*2018 MAC Hermann Trophy Watch List
*2018 BIG EAST Preseason Player of the Year
*2018 Preseason All-BIG EAST First Team
*BIG EAST Offensive Player of the Week (8/26)
*2018 All-BIG EAST First Team
*2018 All-East Region First Team

2018 – Senior Season: 2018 MAC Hermann Trophy Watch List... BIG EAST Preseason Offensive Player of the Year... Preseason All-BIG EAST First Team... First Team All-BIG EAST Selection.. Started in 17 games… Finished the year with two goals and a team-high six assists for 10 total points…  Named the BIG EAST Offensive Player of the Week (8/27) after scoring two goals and one assist against #20 Notre Dame for a season-high point total… Tallied a season-high two assists against IUPUI (Aug. 20)… Had an assist in the 3-2 win over Providence in the BIG EAST semifinals... Took a team-high 51 shots… Came up with a season-high eight shots against Kent State (Aug. 16)… Took six shots against Creighton (Oct. 18)... Named to the 2018 BIG EAST All-Tournament team... Finished career in the Butler record book in all career categories:  #6 in shots with 256... #7 in points with 62... Tied for 8th in assists with 18.... #9 goals with 22.

2017 – Junior Season: BIG EAST Offensive Player of the Year… First Team All-BIG EAST selection… Two-time BIG EAST Offensive Player of the Week selection (9/25, 10/30)… Started in all 21 games… Led the team with 26 points… Scored a team-high 10 goals… Added a team-high six assists… Led the team in total shots with 69… Team leader with 38 shots on goal… Scored four game-winning goals… Went 1-for-1 in PK attempts… Recorded a season-high point total vs. Marquette by scoring two goals and adding an assist (Sept. 24)… Posted four points vs. Villanova (Oct. 26) and at Creighton (Oct. 19) by scoring two goals… Came up with two assists vs. Chicago State (Sept. 21)… Took a season-high seven shots vs. Villanova (Oct. 26)… Recorded five shots on goal at Creighton (Oct. 19)… Scored nine goals against BIG EAST opponents… First point of the season came off an assist in the win at Michigan State (Aug. 24)… Scored a goal in the upset win at #10 Texas A&M (Sept. 8)… Ranked third in the BIG EAST in shots (66) and shots per game (3.30)… Ended the year ranked second in points (26) and points per game (1.30)… Tied for the conference lead in goals scored with 10… Tied for second in the BIG EAST in assists with six… Ranked 48th in the NCAA in shots on goal per game (1.81) and 55th in game-winning goals (4)… Ranked 56th in the NCAA in total points (26)… Ranked 63rd in the NCAA in total goals (10)… Ranked 85th in the NCAA in shots per game (3.29)… Ranked 90th in the nation in points per game (1.24).

2016 - Sophomore Season: Started in all 18 games she appeared in... Finished first on the team in shots (71)...Finished second on the team in goals (6) and points (15)... Finished tied for third on the team in assists (3)... Led the BIG EAST and ranked 33rd nationally in shots per game (3.94)... Earned BIG EAST Offensive Player of the Week honors after a two goal performance against Xavier to earn BU a Conference Tournament berth (10/28)... Her 10 shots in a 2-1 victory over Seton Hall placed her in Butler's all-time top 10 for shots in a match (10/16)... Scored her first two goals of the season and added two assists to enter the top-five in Butler's history for points in a match during a 4-0 victory over Fort Wayne (9/11)... Took four shots on goal in back to back games against Seton Hall and Creighton (10/20).


2015 - Freshman Season: Finished fourth on the team in both goals (4) and points (11)... Played in 23 games, making 17 starts... BIG EAST All-Freshman Team... Led the team to victory by scoring two goals against Eastern Michigan in the home opener (8/24)... Came up with a header goal in the first half, followed by an unassisted score off a rebound in half two... Helped Butler win at IUPUI by recording her first assist of the season (9/1)... Recorded a goal to help Butler to victory over IPFW (9/13)... Came up with a big goal in a 2-1 victory over St. Johns (11/6). Named BIG EAST Offensive Player of the Week (10/31/15)

High School: Four-time All-County, All-Conference, All-Group, and All-State player... Named Morris County Player of the Year, NJAC Player of the Year, Mugs Media Player of the Year, and selected as an All-American player... Broke school records with 29 goals in a single-season and 79 goals in a four-year career... Notched the fastest goal in school history by finding the back of the net in just five seconds... Played for the PDA Clash ECNL team who has been ranked as part of the top eight in the nation the past three years.

Why Monaghan Chose Butler:
"I chose Butler because of the academic reputation, inspiring staff and directors, unique campus, outstanding coaching staff, competitive soccer program and the hardworking and genuine players." 

A Quote from Coach:
"Quite simply, Paige is a handful for defenders to deal with. Fast, direct, confident in 1v1 scenarios and a great striker of the ball. Paige has the rare ability of being able to create chances for herself and for others, and is an excellent addition to our attacking arsenal."